The Way We Live: You Are Quick to Judge Sinners, but How Honest Are You With Yourself?
“Did you hear what that woman did?” Grace asked, adjusting her handbag as she settled into the chair.
“I heard. Honestly, some people have no shame again,” her friend replied, shaking her head.
“And she claims to be a Christian. Can you imagine?”
The conversation continued until their friend Michael, who had been listening quietly, interrupted.
“Before you both finish sentencing her, can I ask something?”
They turned towards him.
“When was the last time you discussed something good she did?”
There was a brief silence.
“Michael, what is your point?” Grace asked.
“My point is simple. We remember people’s mistakes with remarkable accuracy, but somehow develop selective amnesia when it comes to our own.”
Everyone laughed, but the question stayed in the room.

It is interesting how easily we become experts in other people’s shortcomings. We can identify dishonesty, pride, gossip, immorality and greed from a distance, yet struggle to recognise similar habits when they appear in our own lives.
Someone makes a mistake, and we quickly become a panel of judges. We discuss the person’s character, question their upbringing and sometimes turn one unfortunate incident into a permanent identity.
Yet, when our own behaviour comes under scrutiny, we suddenly remember that nobody is perfect.
A man who cheats on his wife may condemn another man for doing the same. A woman who spreads rumours may spend an entire afternoon discussing somebody else’s gossiping habit. Someone who refuses to forgive may describe another person as bitter.
We can be very generous with criticism and surprisingly economical with self-examination.
One Sunday after church, a young woman overheard two members discussing a lady who had been caught in an embarrassing situation.
“She should be ashamed of herself,” one said.
“Exactly! Some people have no fear of God,” the other added.
The young woman listened before asking, “But didn’t you tell us last week that you had apologised to your husband for the things you said about him?”
The woman frowned.
“That is a different matter.”
And there it was: the famous human defence mechanism called my own case is different.
Our mistakes often come with explanations, background stories and requests for understanding. Other people’s mistakes, however, are sometimes treated as evidence that they are beyond redemption.
Consider another situation. A group of friends in London are having dinner when one begins discussing a colleague who was recently disciplined for dishonesty.
“He has destroyed his reputation. I don’t know how anyone can trust him again,” she says.
Her friend puts down his glass.
“That’s quite a strong judgment. Have you forgotten the money you borrowed from Sarah and never returned?”
“That’s not the same thing,” she replies.
“Of course. Your own case came with a special exemption!”
The table erupts in laughter, but the point is difficult to dismiss. We often demand accountability from others while negotiating endlessly with our own conscience.
This is where Jesus’ teaching in Matthew 7:3–5 becomes particularly uncomfortable. He asks why someone notices the speck in another person’s eye while failing to recognise the plank in their own.

Jesus was not teaching people to ignore wrongdoing or abandon moral standards. He was challenging the hypocrisy of correcting others while refusing to confront personal faults.
The same warning appears in Romans 2:1, where Paul cautions those who judge others while practising the very things they condemn. It is a sobering reminder that our criticism does not automatically make us innocent.
There is also a difference between correcting someone and condemning them. Correction should help people recognise what is wrong and make better choices; condemnation often leaves little room for growth.
Galatians 6:1 offers a helpful instruction: when someone is caught in wrongdoing, those who are spiritual should restore that person gently, while watching themselves so they are not tempted too.
Notice the emphasis on gentleness and self-awareness. The Bible does not ask us to celebrate wrongdoing, but it cautions us against approaching another person’s weakness with arrogance.
In John 8:7, Jesus tells those ready to stone a woman caught in adultery, “He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.”
The lesson was not that wrongdoing suddenly became acceptable. It was a reminder that the people demanding punishment also needed to examine themselves.
Sometimes, we behave as though our own sins have been written in pencil while everyone else’s are permanently engraved in stone.
The danger of this attitude is that it makes us comfortable with religious appearances while neglecting the character that should accompany our faith.
A person can know when to stand during worship, quote several Bible verses and lead a prayer beautifully, yet struggle to speak kindly to a house help, pay a debt or apologise after hurting someone.
A well-known line from Socrates says, “The unexamined life is not worth living.” It reminds us that reflection matters. We cannot keep improving our lives if we refuse to look honestly at the people we are becoming.
William Shakespeare also wrote in Hamlet, “To thine own self be true.” That advice speaks directly to the importance of personal honesty, even when the truth is uncomfortable.
Paul makes this point practical in Galatians 6:4, encouraging each person to examine their own actions rather than measuring themselves against somebody else.
Personal accountability should occupy more of our attention than the endless business of comparing lives.
This conversation is not limited to church members in Lagos, Abuja or London. Across communities in Africa, Europe, America and beyond, people face the same temptation to measure others with strict standards while giving themselves generous allowances.
Social media has made the habit even more visible. A stranger’s mistake can attract thousands of comments, insults and moral lectures within minutes.
Yet, some of those typing the harshest judgments would struggle to accept the same treatment if their private mistakes became public.
Imagine if every comment we posted about another person’s failure appeared beside a record of our own behaviour. Many of us might suddenly become interested in switching off the internet!
There is nothing wrong with recognising harmful behaviour. We should speak against abuse, dishonesty, exploitation and injustice. Silence should never be mistaken for kindness.
But the person correcting wrongdoing must also be willing to live by the values being defended. Otherwise, our criticism becomes a performance, and our faith becomes a garment we wear in public but remove when nobody is watching.
Perhaps the question we should ask more often is not simply, “What is wrong with that person?” but also, “What needs attention in my own life?”
You may not have committed the same offence as someone else, but that does not automatically make you a better person. Pride, cruelty, dishonesty, envy and unforgiveness can wear respectable clothing too.
God does not ask us to pretend we are perfect. He calls us to humility, repentance, love and a willingness to grow.
Before you pick up another person’s mistakes like evidence in a courtroom, take a moment to inspect your own conduct. You may discover that your hands are not as clean as your arguments suggest.

Personal Thoughts:
It takes little effort to point at another person’s weakness. It takes courage to admit when our own behaviour needs correction. Genuine growth begins when we stop treating self-examination as an insult.
One Thing Worth Remembering:
You can recognise wrongdoing without becoming self-righteous. Correct with compassion, speak with wisdom and remember that the person you are judging is also a human being capable of change.
Let’s Talk:
Why are we often quicker to expose other people’s mistakes than to acknowledge our own? Can someone genuinely practise Christianity while constantly judging others but refusing to examine their own character?
Short Prayer:
Heavenly Father, give us humble hearts and the courage to recognise our own shortcomings. Teach us to correct with love, forgive with sincerity and live by the values we profess. Help us grow in character and show others the same mercy we desire for ourselves., in Jesus Name, Amen.
Leave a comment