‘No One Will Disrespect Our Lady of Aparecida’ — Religious Row Rocks Brazil Election
A religious controversy surrounding Brazil’s patron saint, Our Lady of Aparecida, has become an unexpected issue in the final days before the country’s presidential election.
President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and his challenger, Flávio Bolsonaro, are heading into Sunday’s vote amid a closely fought contest, with religion now adding another sensitive issue to the campaign.
The controversy centres on speculation that Bolsonaro could seek to remove Our Lady of Aparecida from her position as Brazil’s patroness if elected president.
The debate gained momentum after Bolsonaro said during a recent broadcast that one of his first actions as president would be to “decree that Brazil belongs to the Lord Jesus Christ.”
Some Catholics interpreted the statement as a possible indication that the Protestant politician could challenge the position of Our Lady of Aparecida.
However, Bolsonaro has rejected the claim, describing reports that he intends to remove the patroness as “fake news.”
He has accused supporters of Lula and the Episcopal Conference of Brazil, the country’s Catholic bishops’ organisation, of spreading the allegation.
The bishops’ conference has denied Bolsonaro’s accusation, while the controversy continues to generate strong reactions among Catholics across the country.
Our Lady of Aparecida was declared Brazil’s patroness by the Vatican in 1930 and remains one of the most recognised religious figures in the country.
The issue has gained political significance because Catholics account for nearly 57 per cent of Brazil’s population, while evangelical Christians make up about 30 per cent.
Lula has seized on the controversy during his campaign appearances, publicly defending the religious tradition and appearing with statues of the Virgin Mary.
“As long as I’m president, no one will disrespect Our Lady of Aparecida. No one. People need to learn to respect all religions,” Lula said at a campaign rally in the Amazon.
Lula’s running mate, Geraldo Alckmin, has also sought to reassure Catholic voters who expressed concern over reports about the possible removal of the patroness.
In a video message, Alckmin said he had received messages from Catholics worried about the direction of the country and assured them that religious traditions considered sacred by Brazilian families would be preserved and protected.
Political analyst Thomas Traumann said the controversy had touched an existing tension surrounding the growing influence of evangelical Christians in Brazilian politics.
He said evangelical political influence is particularly strong within the movement supporting Bolsonaro, making religious questions especially sensitive during the election.
The dispute also reflects a much longer rivalry between Brazil’s historically dominant Catholic Church and rapidly expanding evangelical churches.
Historian Luiz Antônio Simas said the reaction surrounding Aparecida demonstrated the importance of the Virgin Mary in Brazilian culture.
According to Simas, Our Lady of Aparecida has a place beyond Catholic worship, with her image and symbolism appearing in samba culture, football and Afro-Brazilian religious traditions.
The historian also pointed to a previous controversy in 1995, when a neo-Pentecostal pastor kicked a statue of Our Lady of Aparecida during a television programme, triggering widespread condemnation.
Simas said the saint’s identity as a Black representation of the Virgin Mary also adds a racial dimension to the debate surrounding her place in Brazilian culture.
As voters prepare to choose their next president, the dispute over Our Lady of Aparecida has therefore become part of a wider conversation about religion, cultural identity and political power in Brazil.
Whether the controversy will influence voting decisions remains uncertain, but its emergence in the final stage of the campaign has placed Brazil’s patron saint at the centre of an unusually charged election debate.
Leave a comment